People don’t care about future pain or future reward. Build your marketing around either one and that’s why it’s not working.
This isn’t a knock on your prospects. It’s a documented feature of how human brains handle decisions, and it has a name: temporal discounting.
What Temporal Discounting Actually Means
Temporal discounting is the tendency to value things less the further away they are in time. A hundred dollars today beats a hundred and ten next month, even when the math is obvious. Research published in the Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis confirms what most people already feel: the steeper the delay, the steeper the drop in perceived value. Nobody decides to discount the future. It just happens.
For marketers, that’s a structural problem. Every piece of copy that chases a future outcome fights a cognitive bias your prospect doesn’t even know they have.
Your Brain Discounts Future Pain Too
Most people understand this concept when money enters the picture. Fewer apply it to consequences.
The churn problem nobody fixed, the ad spend nobody can trace to revenue, the competitor quietly outranking them on searches that matter. All of it feels manageable because the bill hasn’t come due yet. So they sit on it, not out of laziness, but because future pain registers as a distant abstraction.
Your prospect has known for months that something broke. They nod when you name it. They’ll agree something needs to change. Then they do nothing, because “eventually” carries no weight.
Why “Imagine What You Could Achieve” Falls Flat
Leading with the future state is the most common mistake in marketing copy. Better revenue, a stronger brand, the system that finally runs itself. None of it moves anyone.
Future tense is where gain lives. Their brain discounts it before the sentence is done.
“Imagine what you could achieve with a real retention strategy” asks someone to assign value to something that doesn’t exist yet. Brains discount it automatically. Desire might be real. Urgency isn’t.
Kahneman and Tversky’s work on loss aversion puts numbers to it: losses register roughly twice as intensely as equivalent gains. Losing a hundred dollars hurts more than finding a hundred dollars feels good. Loss is present tense. Gain is aspirational. That asymmetry is why loss framing outperforms benefit framing almost every time.
Present tense is where loss lives. Gain is aspirational. Writing marketing copy that leads with future benefit asks someone to feel urgency about something their brain already wrote off.
How to Make the Cost Feel Real Now
The goal isn’t to scare anyone. It’s to make the consequence of inaction land in the present, where it actually changes behavior.
Compare these two framings:
“A real retention strategy could add six figures to your annual revenue.”
“You lost clients last quarter who could have stayed. That revenue is already gone.”
The first asks someone to imagine a future. That second framing describes something that already happened and can’t be undone. One falls away. The past carries full weight.
Discovery conversations work the same way. Asking a prospect what they hope to achieve pulls them toward a future they can’t feel. Pulling the conversation toward what they lost last quarter, what they couldn’t measure, what decisions they made without reliable data, puts the cost somewhere they can actually touch it.
This Is What Makes Gap Selling Work
Temporal discounting is the behavioral mechanism underneath gap selling. Keenan’s gap between current state and future state isn’t just a strategic concept. Psychology drives it.
Sizing the gap isn’t about making the problem feel big. Making it feel present is the goal. A prospect who says “I’ve probably lost three clients this year because we had no retention system” isn’t describing a risk. They’re describing money that already walked out the door. That’s a present-tense loss, and it carries a weight that no future-benefit pitch ever will.
Someone describing money they’ve already lost isn’t weighing options. At that point, something needs to change is no longer a question.
What to Do With This Before Your Next Piece of Copy
Before writing a headline, a subject line, or an opening sentence, ask one question: am I pointing at something that already happened, or something that might happen someday?
If the answer is someday, find the version of that same idea that’s already true. Already sitting in last quarter’s numbers. Already costing something. Already gone.
The archetypes in the BBS Marketing Diagnostic work because they describe what’s already happening, specifically enough that the person reading them recognizes their own situation. Recognition is a present-tense experience. When someone sees their business in a description, the cost stops being abstract.
Lead with the leak. Not the dream.
Take the free BBS Marketing Diagnostic to find out which pattern your marketing is right now. It takes five minutes.
About the Author
Mike Birt is Co-Founder and Lead Strategist at Big Brain Strategy. He spent over a decade solving growth problems for businesses that had hit a wall, including serving as CMO at Grunt Style, where he helped grow the company from $6M to $80M. Along the way he built a 75-person marketing team, managing a $16M annual budget, growing an email list from under 100,000 to over 2 million subscribers, and creating a loyalty program generating over $1M in monthly recurring revenue. Today he works with business owners and marketing leaders who need a strategist, not another vendor. Mike is a proud United States Army veteran.
Leave a Reply